Editorial Policies

1. Journal, Publisher, and Editorial Independence

Data & Science is an international, peer-reviewed, fully open-access scholarly journal published by CSCHOLAR. The journal’s academic mission and subject areas are described in its Aims and Scope at https://ds.cscholar.com/about.

Editorial decisions are based on research quality, originality, methodological or analytical rigor, relevance, ethical compliance, and contribution to scholarship. Neither APC payment, waiver eligibility, commercial considerations, personal relationships, institutional pressure nor the publisher’s administrative interests may determine an editorial decision.

The publisher provides platform, editorial-support, production, communication, and administrative services. The Editor-in-Chief and appropriately delegated academic editors retain authority over scholarly assessments and final decisions. Administrative and production staff may conduct technical checks and coordinate review but do not independently accept or reject manuscripts on scholarly grounds.

2. Roles and Responsibilities

Editors-in-Chief: provide scientific leadership, maintain the journal’s aims and scope, oversee quality and ethics, supervise editorial performance, manage conflicts and difficult cases, appoint qualified academic editors, and make or authorize final editorial decisions.

Associate Editors: manage assigned submissions when delegated; assess scope and quality; select or recommend independent reviewers; evaluate review reports and revisions; make a decision within delegated authority or recommend an outcome to the Editor-in-Chief; and refer conflicts or ethical issues to an unconflicted editor.

Editorial Board Members: advise on the journal’s development and scholarly standards; help identify qualified reviewers and prospective research areas; perform reviews and, only when explicitly delegated, act as handling academic editors. Board membership alone does not confer unrestricted decision-making authority.

Editorial Office and publisher staff: coordinate submissions, technical checks, reviewer communications, deadlines, production, metadata and author support while protecting confidentiality and maintaining records. They must not influence academic decisions based on APC status or commercial considerations.

Guest Editors: may oversee approved special collections within a documented mandate, but remain subject to the journal’s peer-review, conflict-of-interest and academic oversight rules. An Editor-in-Chief or an unconflicted delegated academic editor retains overall responsibility for special-issue content.

3. Initial Assessment and Peer Review

The journal applies double-blind peer review. Authors submit an anonymized manuscript and a separate title page; authors and reviewers are not informed of each other’s identities during review to the extent practicable. Editorial staff and handling editors may know author identities as needed for administration and integrity checks, and must maintain confidentiality.

Each submission undergoes technical screening and an academic initial assessment of scope, originality, basic integrity and scholarly suitability. A handling academic editor may reject a submission without external review when it does not meet the journal’s standards; the reason will be communicated to the author.

Each manuscript selected for publication through the standard review pathway must receive reports from at least two suitably qualified independent experts. Reviewers are selected for competence, impartiality and independence. Editors may seek additional reviews, including when reports disagree materially.

The journal ordinarily permits no more than three rounds of major revision; further consideration depends on the judgment of the handling academic editor. Revision deadlines are stated individually in decision letters, and reasonable extensions may be requested.

Final decisions on acceptance or rejection are made by the Editor-in-Chief or a delegated, unconflicted academic editor after considering reviewers’ reports, the manuscript and any revisions. Reviewer recommendations do not by themselves constitute editorial decisions.

4. Reviewer Independence, Confidentiality, and Open Reports

Reviewers must disclose competing interests, including close personal or professional relationships, current institutional overlap, and recent joint publications with authors. Reviewers are normally expected not to have coauthored work with the authors within the preceding three years. Reviews must be impartial, respectful, specific and free from coercive citation requests.

Editors, reviewers and editorial staff must treat submissions, manuscripts, associated data, and review communications as confidential. Reviewers may not delegate reviews or share materials without prior authorization; all participants must protect identifying information under the double-blind model.

Open peer review is optional and does not alter the journal’s default double-blind review model. A review report may be released alongside an accepted article only if the relevant author(s) and the individual reviewer expressly agree. The reviewer’s identity remains confidential unless that reviewer separately provides explicit consent to disclosure. Consent to publication of a report is not a condition of review participation.

5. Mandatory Similarity Standard and Plagiarism

The journal applies a mandatory similarity-screening standard: the measured manuscript similarity score must be strictly below 20% under the journal’s designated checking procedure. Submissions with scores of 20% or higher do not satisfy the technical requirement for progression to external peer review unless an invited revision is rechecked and passes.

The similarity figure is not an automatic or conclusive judgment of plagiarism. Editors independently evaluate the nature and context of overlapping text, including quotations, references, common technical language and possible text recycling. Even a score below 20% cannot excuse plagiarism or other improper reuse.

Similarity checks may be repeated on revised and accepted manuscripts. If the final text fails the mandatory standard, production is paused pending correction and verification. Suspected intentional evasion, substantial unattributed reuse, or other misconduct is subject to the journal’s integrity procedures.

6. Artificial Intelligence Policies

Authors may use generative AI and AI-assisted tools responsibly in research and manuscript preparation, but remain accountable for every claim, source, figure, dataset and analysis. Such tools are not eligible for authorship.

Authors must disclose substantive use of generative AI or AI-assisted tools at submission and in the manuscript, including the tool and its purpose and extent of use. Disclosures must cover, where applicable, study design, content generation, coding, data processing and analysis, translation, and figure or image creation. Routine basic spelling or grammar correction need not be disclosed. The journal may request clarification or evidence concerning the accuracy of a declaration.

The journal may perform automated AIGC screening. The recommendation that an AIGC detection result be below 25% is purely advisory: it is not a required threshold, not a direct measure of misconduct, and not an automatic basis for deciding whether to review, accept, or reject. Any concerns arising from automated indicators are examined by a qualified human editor alongside the manuscript and declarations.

Reviewers and academic editors must not upload confidential manuscripts or related material to external generative-AI systems, and must not delegate substantive scholarly evaluation to AI. Routine local language or spelling checks may be used. Other limited language-assistance use is subject to the safeguards and disclosures described in For Reviewers. Editorial decisions remain human decisions.

7. Authorship, Contributorship, and Publication Originality

All authors must make genuine scholarly contributions, approve the submitted and final manuscript, and accept appropriate responsibility for their work. The corresponding author confirms agreement among coauthors. The journal recommends a transparent contribution statement, using the CRediT taxonomy where suitable.

The submission must not be under simultaneous consideration at another journal. Authors must disclose relevant preprints, conference versions, related submissions and substantial text or data overlap. Posting a disclosed preprint is not automatically treated as prior journal publication, but duplicate or redundant journal publication is prohibited.

Requests to change authorship after submission require a written explanation and agreement from all affected authors. Where a dispute cannot be resolved by the authors, the journal may suspend processing and request clarification from the relevant institution.

8. Research Ethics, Consent, and Data Integrity

Authors must comply with applicable ethical, regulatory and institutional requirements. Where human participants, identifiable personal data, animals, or ethically sensitive research materials are involved, authors must provide appropriate approval and consent statements or explain why approval or consent was not required.

Authors must protect privacy and confidentiality; secure permissions for third-party materials; and accurately describe collection, sampling, preprocessing, analysis, limitations and uncertainties. Data fabrication, falsification, image manipulation that misleads readers, fabricated citations, and selective reporting intended to misrepresent findings are prohibited.

Authors must provide a data-availability statement appropriate to the study. The journal encourages making underlying data, code, methods and supporting materials available where ethically, legally and contractually feasible. Legitimate restrictions—such as confidentiality, personal-data protection, proprietary licensing or provider conditions—must be clearly explained. Reproducibility does not imply that protected data must be redistributed unlawfully.

9. Competing Interests, Funding, and Citation Integrity

Authors, reviewers and editors must disclose relevant financial and non-financial competing interests, including employment, grants, ownership interests, personal relationships, academic rivalry, and competing professional commitments. An absence of competing interests should also be stated by authors.

Authors must identify research funding and relevant sponsor roles. Funders and sponsors do not control editorial decisions. Citations should serve scholarly relevance and verification rather than artificially increasing journal, author, reviewer or editorial metrics. The journal prohibits citation coercion, citation cartels, and other deliberate manipulation of research assessment indicators.

10. Editorial Conflicts and Submissions by Board Members

An editor must not handle a submission in which they are an author, have a close relationship with an author, have been recently involved in the research, or have any other material conflict. Conflicted editors must recuse themselves before reviewer selection, assessment and decision.

Manuscripts authored by Editors-in-Chief, Associate Editors, Board Members, editorial staff or Guest Editors are subject to the same technical checks and independent double-blind review standards as other submissions. An unconflicted academic editor with appropriate authority handles the case, and the author-editor has no access to confidential decisions or reviewer assignments for that manuscript.

Special-issue contributions from Guest Editors must be handled independently, with oversight from an Editor-in-Chief or appropriately delegated, unconflicted editor. The journal may limit the proportion of such contributions to maintain editorial independence.

11. Post-Publication Corrections and Retractions

The journal is committed to maintaining an accurate and trustworthy scholarly record. Where warranted by credible evidence, the journal may publish a correction, expression of concern, retraction, or other clearly labelled notice. Notices are linked to the affected article, explain the reason to the extent appropriate, and preserve an accessible record.

Corrections address errors that materially affect accuracy but do not invalidate the central findings. An expression of concern may be used while a serious unresolved matter is investigated. Retractions are considered when findings are unreliable, unethical research is established, publication is redundant or unlawful, or serious integrity failures undermine the article.

Authors will normally have an opportunity to respond before a final publication-integrity decision. The journal may consult independent experts, institutions, rights holders or other journals where necessary and proportionate. Publication notices are decided on evidentiary grounds, not on an author’s willingness to agree.

12. Allegations, Complaints, and Appeals

Concerns may be submitted confidentially to authorsupport@cscholar.com with the article or manuscript identifier and supporting information. The journal will acknowledge the concern, evaluate its credibility, maintain appropriate confidentiality, and arrange impartial consideration by an unconflicted editor. Serious allegations may require expert or institutional input.

Persons whose conduct is questioned will normally be given a reasonable opportunity to respond before final conclusions are reached. Confidentiality is maintained as far as practicable while preserving fair procedure and the integrity of the research record.

Authors may appeal an editorial decision by providing a specific explanation of a possible procedural error, factual misunderstanding, conflict of interest or material new information. Mere disagreement with reviewer opinion is not by itself sufficient. Appeals are evaluated by an unconflicted senior academic editor, and where appropriate by an independent adviser. The outcome will be communicated in writing.

Complaints involving an Editor-in-Chief are referred to another unconflicted senior academic editor and the publisher for procedural oversight, without allowing publishing staff to determine the scientific merits of a submission.

13. Special Issues and Editorial Collections

Special issues and collections must fall within the published Aims and Scope and follow the journal’s standards for authorship, originality, similarity screening, AI disclosure, peer review, conflicts, fees and editorial independence.

Guest Editors are selected for subject expertise and appropriate standing, and are monitored by an Editor-in-Chief or delegated academic editor. All research articles receive at least two independent expert reviews under the journal’s double-blind procedures. Guest Editors may not make final decisions on their own manuscripts; those papers are assigned independently.

The journal will clearly identify special-issue articles and any material deviation from routine peer-review procedures, if such a deviation is legitimately necessary and permitted.

14. Open Access, Licence, Copyright, and Deposits

All published articles are immediately accessible without reader subscription charges. Articles are licensed under Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International (CC BY 4.0), https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/. Authors retain copyright and authorize CSCHOLAR and the journal to publish and disseminate the version of record. Proper attribution and indication of licence conditions are required; third-party material excluded from the licence must be identified.

Authors may deposit submitted, accepted and published versions in appropriate repositories or websites with accurate version and publication attribution. The journal encourages proper citation of the version of record and its DOI where available.

15. APC Policy and Academic Independence

The standard APC is USD 400 per accepted article, exclusive of any applicable VAT or local taxes, and is assessed under the fee schedule in effect at acceptance. There is no APC payment at submission or while a manuscript is under peer review, and the journal charges no separate submission, page or colour-figure fees.

All manuscripts initially submitted on or before December 31, 2029 receive a full APC waiver, regardless of later acceptance or publication date. The time-limited waiver is automatic. For manuscripts outside that period, low-income-economy full waivers, lower-middle-income-economy discounts, and additional financial-need requests are administered in accordance with the For Authors page.

APC payments, discounts and waiver requests are strictly separated from scholarly evaluation. Optional publishing or language services are not prerequisites for peer review or acceptance.

16. Privacy and Contact

The journal processes author, editor and reviewer data for legitimate editorial and publishing purposes in accordance with its Privacy Statement (https://ds.cscholar.com/about/privacy). Published scholarly content and author attribution are distinct from confidential manuscript and peer-review records.

For publication-ethics matters, appeals, or administrative questions, contact authorsupport@cscholar.com or use the journal’s submission system. The Editorial Policies are intended to be read consistently with the For Authors and For Reviewers pages; where an ambiguity is identified, the journal will clarify its published rule before applying it.